BabyGearLab US · Editorial review
BabyGearLab Best Crib Mattresses (updated April 8, 2025)
47%
Our scale47
weight 0.60
- Materials (50%)
- 2.0
- Sheet Changing (30%)
- 7.5
- Crib Fit (20%)
- 7.0
Listed at $200
Moonlight Slumber · Crib mattress
Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer
Based on 1 independent scored test: BabyGearLab (2025).
Tested for US & Canada
47
Shortlist score
Fair
#22 of baby mattresses
Single test
Where to buy
Most links search the shop for this model. Check that the version on sale matches the one tested.
Test results
Each score as the tester published it, converted to our 0–100 scale. Weight is how much the result counts towards the score.
Top-ranked alternatives
- 68My Green Mattress Emily NaturalBabyGearLab 75%
- 68Newton OriginalBabyGearLab 75%
- 68Naturepedic Organic Cotton Classic 150 Seamless 2-StageBabyGearLab 74%
- 66Avocado OrganicBabyGearLab 71%
- 64Babyletto Pure Core with Dry Waterproof CoverBabyGearLab 67%
How we turn these into one number: methodology. Tested in 2025.